Stone Circles and the Scientific Method

Every once in a while, a story will come up like it did near the end of of January. A stone circle which had been identified as being between 3,500 and 4,000 years old.  At its face value, a story like this may cause us to question whether scientists (in this case maybe archaeologists or geologists) really know what they are doing. Then we might doubt the scientific method. 

 Some things to keep in mind at this point though:
1. The circle never had a completed study done on it. 
2. Even if it had, individuals in science do make mistakes.
3. ^ This is why we have peer reviewed journals as well as plenty of other forums to see if someone's findings are worth believing or not. 
4. In other words, science and the way we carry out the scientific method does not and should not happen in a vacuum. 
5. Testing can and should be rigorous.
6. Question everything. Believe some things. Think about how you know.  
7. Be careful how and when you present things. 
8. Science as a discipline has not been hurt by the missteps of a few people involved in this particular case. 

 Those are my takeaways from this incident. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Thanks for your comments. As soon as your comment has been screened and approved it will appear. Please remember that no hateful written speech, trolling, or advertising will be allowed.

Popular posts from this blog

Expectations and Desire

Image
Life rarely presents what we expected. I am reminded of this daily in the lives of my two young sons. As they grow and learn each day unfolds uniquely. I try to develop routines with them, but no two days are ever the same. This change, or at least their reactions to change, means I have to be ready for anything. I often fail. Usually, my attitude just doesn't keep up with what those two throw at me. Sometimes they are having a rough day and I have a bad attitude. The next day when they're ready to move on and have a good day, my bad attitude sticks around. I'm good at controlling it around them. However, the bad attitude seeps out when I'm around my wife or other adults.(I'm sorry if your one of those people I've treated unfairly). The problem with all of this happens to be my expectations. Is it that my expectations are unrealistic? Possibly. Or maybe they are too imposing on other people (such as the boys)? That might be true too. Maybe I just have too m
Read more

Listening

Image
Photo by  Louie Castro-Garcia  on  Unsplash Like most people, there are time when I want to check out mentally and stop listening when someone is talking.  Last night I had one of those experiences. I was ready to go home, my eyes were tired, and it had been a long day.  Then I asked a question.  One of the guys I had played games with suddenly became far more talkative to me than he ever had been. I had already wondered that night if this person was capable of saying something that wasn't sarcastic or negative. I found out he was capable of this simple feat! He began to passionately share with me about his daughters, and then one of his favorite games. He talked for at least fifteen minutes without saying a single negative thing. I was amazed. I struggled to contain my tiredness, but I made a mental note to stay close physically to the conversation and to continue to make eye contact. By the end of the conversation, I could tell he had shared most of what he wanted to
Read more

Dinomania - A Short Review

Image
Most people enjoy a good work of fiction, and this book is no exception if encountered with that expectation in mind. Unfortunately, the author attempted to write more of a sociological commentary on our relationship with dinosaurs. Most of the book addresses the Western perspective on dinosaurs, but there are sections which show global development. Where Boria does well is inviting the reader to re-imagine our relationship with dinosaurs in such way that are not just over-commercialized kitsch.  He also invites the reader to view dinosaurs through different historical-cultural lenses which show up most readily in artistic renderings of dinosaurs from the last two hundred years.  Prominently, the Crystal Palace dinosaurs show how Imperial Britain viewed dinosaurs as an extension of her own place in the world. There are a few areas where to book fails. It is obviously influenced by post-modern constructive views which leave you wondering what exactly a dinosaur actually is without
Read more